In The Gay Science (1882)
and Twilight of the idols (1889),
Nietzsche give us his conception of the relation between humanity and religion,
existence and religion. I want to explore here how the drama “Waiting for Godot”, of Samuel Beckett
can be read as an illustration of the ideas of Nietzsche about existence.
First, let us try to sum up “Waiting for
Godot”. In this play, two characters, Estragon and Vladimir are waiting for a
so called “Godot”, discussing without having nothing to say.
During the whole
play, they try not to be bored by the life. Of course, Godot never comes and
the two characters cannot move away because they are waiting for him, but on
the other hand they have nothing to do where they are, and the whole drama
takes place in this sort of stillness. The same story repeats itself two days a
row, and nothing changes.
Death through waiting.
This Play can be related with Nietzsche’s ideas
about religion. Indeed, we cannot prevent us of seeing a strange similarity
between Godot and God, this being we are waiting all life long, without knowing
if he will come one day. The characters do not really know what Godot looks
like, when he will come, they are not even sure the place there are is the
right place of meeting. All these characteristics allow us to think that Godot
can be seen as an allegory of God. Then
we have to see what Gogo and Didi are doing, waiting for God. One of the most
important idea of Beckett’s play is that conversations, as the lives of the characters,
are empty; the only thing they can do is to wait. Life is not more life, in
that sense that Estragon and Vladimir do not have vital impulse, they speak to
fight boredom, they have argue not to see the time flowing. The best example of
this non-life state is that when Estragon says “What about hang ourselves?”
Vladimir answers “Hum, It’d give us an erection”. One sentence of Twilight of the Idols can perfectly
summarize this situation: “Life has come to an end where the “kingdom of God”
begins”. There is no more life in the two characters relation, because they are
waiting for God.
Passions: something forbidden.
And the
relation between the two authors does not stop here. We have now to think about
passions and feelings in the story. What can strike the spectator of the drama
is that no one really have passions. The characters do not allow them to feel
something. Vladimir says at once “You would make me laugh, if that was allowed”,
this sentence can lead us to introduce two ideas of Nietzsche. The first is the
idea that religion and consequently Church are deadly hostile to sensuality.
The state of religious waiting that are living Estragon and Vladimir does not
allow them to feel anything, they have to follow moral principles that kill
feelings. The second idea we can see in this little sentence, is the fact that
Nietzsche calls “the condemnation pronounced by the condemned”; following the
moral direction of religion is a choice of men. In the story, they are waiting
for Godot because they have chosen it, and not because they are obligated to do
this!
And we can
say that religion does a good job, our characters do not have passions anymore.
They experience some little feelings which go away as fast as they went.
Sadness and anger are brief and Gogo and Didi skip it quickly.
The end of passions comes with the end of
thought.
To conclude
and to overcome the previous theses, I would like to speak about thought in Waiting for Godot, because this area is
maybe the only which cannot be considered in Nietzsche’s perspective. Indeed,
in Twilight of the idols, we can read
that the religion kills life because Nietzsche considers that life is feeling,
but religion does not kill thought. And S. Beckett go further since he breaks
the thought in his play. The thoughts of characters are not really interesting
and their only value is to help to spend time. The best example of this idea is
Lucky’s tirade in the first act, when he answers to the order “now think”. This
monologue is a four pages text, without any dot, without any comma, and of
course without any sense. The thought is here destructed, as if the last wall
which separated man and nothingness had been destroyed. Which this tirade, men
die even more strongly.
No comments:
Post a Comment